Estonia Considers Its Monuments

Estonia’s Justice Minister, Urmas Reinsalu, said early in January that the government could take down the Soviet war memorial at Maarjamäe because it is falling apart and it is not on the official list of historic monuments. This led Prime Minister Jüri Ratas to suggest that the entire area, which includes a German cemetary and a memorial under construction to the victims of Communism, be designated a historic area.

The Soviet Union built many war memorials across its territory, particularly to commemorate World War II, or the Great Patriotic War, as they call it. I find those monuments moving; they are, after all, memorials to people who died in wars and who had families who grieved them. I’ve been to the Maarjamäe memorial a few times.

One of those times I visited with a graduate student who was studying monuments in the former Soviet Union. As we see now in the United States, monuments are a part of a country’s story of itself. The Soviet Union particularly wanted to erase the past.

60008 27 800 px

The Maarjamäe obelisk was built in 1960 to commemorate Russian troops killed in 1918, during Estonia’s war of independence. Before that, a German cemetry had been there since 1941. A newer memorial has been built by a German organization, with the names of those buried there. My friend and I started to read the names. The first was of a German woman. We looked at the dates. She was the same age when she died as my friend was then. We cried.

Here is the German cemetery as it looked when we were there in August 2000. During the construction of the new monument to Communism, more German graves have been found.

60008 31 800 px

In 1975, other parts of the Soviet memorial were added, along with an eternal flame. The flame was below the hands. In 2000 there were graffiti, and plants were beginning to grow between the paving blocks. Most of this has been cleaned up.

In 2007, the Estonian government moved a Soviet World War II monument from central Tallinn to a cemetery outside of town. The monument, a statue of a soldier with unknown soldiers buried beneath, was on a busy road and usually graced with broken liquor bottles. I thought that putting it in a cemetery was an improvement.

But the Russian government didn’t agree and subjected Estonia to a series of attacks on its electronic infrastructure. Estonia kept the statue in the cemetery, and the attacks ended after a couple of weeks.

It looks like the Maarjamäe monument will not be removed. The Russian government has not objected to the building of the new monument. But it is something they might use if they wanted to accuse Estonia of something.

 

In other news about Estonia, this looks like a good documentary about Estonia just after the fall of the Soviet Union. And it would allow me to practice my Estonian. With subtitles.

 

Cross-posted at Balloon Juice.

One comment

  1. J R in WV · January 16

    Hi Cheryl.

    Off Topic, but on a topic I thought you might find a little interesting. I don’t go on about it but I am a big rock and mineral specimen collector, both by purchase and, at least in the past, field collecting with pick and shovel, hammer and chisel. More recently, as display space becomes filled and my ability to dig and cut bedrock vanishes, I have lately been buying very small specimens, sometimes called thumbnails, and cut stones.

    A fellow well know in the collecting community from Oregon recently offered some things he had faceted for sale, artificial stones mostly, which are affordable compared to cutting rough stones. His faceting patterns are very interesting, nothing like what you see in commercial jewelry stores, and the material he cuts is interesting and varied too. Lots of stones he has collected in the northwest.

    He has – for example – cut some leaded glass windows from viewing ports into Hanford reactors into faceted stones. It’s quite interesting, kind of darkened a little, not like amber but in that direction. Collectors out there need to make sure that when they find something they can tell if it’s a radioactive mineral, and mostly have various detectors for that purpose, and he says it’s no more radioactive than other stones commonly faceted.

    Here is a naked link to a page listing 20 or so stones, the two Hanford leaded glass – oh darn, he’s already taken them down and replaced them with new stuff to sell. I can send you a picture of one that’s slightly damaged was was not for sale if you share an email address and are interested.

    Thanks for your participation at Balloon Juice, you’re a great factual addition to the conversation!

    JR Hodel
    Tango, WV

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s